Defamatory statements on social media have become far more common than those in the printed press. Social platforms often remove pornographic or illegal content, but defamatory content is less policed, making it easy for users to view, like or share it. (For the legal basics, see our guide to social media defamation laws.)
Online defamation follows defamation law closely, meaning that a false statement seen by even one person other than its author and its subject can support a defamation claim. However, to protect free speech under the First Amendment, the Supreme Court has made it harder for public figures to win defamation cases. Even if a public figure proves a statement was false, they must also prove actual malice, meaning the speaker knew it was false or acted with reckless disregard for the truth.
What Is Social Media Defamation?
There are two types of defamation: slander, which is spoken, and libel, which is written or published. For a social media statement to be defamatory, it must refer to the claimant, harm the claimant’s reputation and be false. Because social media posts can reach a large audience quickly, defamatory comments there can cause financial losses and emotional distress.
Usually, the author of the defamatory comment is liable. Platforms are generally shielded from liability for users’ posts by Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act, though an employer can sometimes be responsible for statements an employee makes on the job.
Types of Social Media Defamation
Social media consists of several platforms where people can post content, comments, photographs, and even videos. These include Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, YouTube, TikTok, LinkedIn, and Pinterest.
Common ways people defame others on social media include:
- Posts published on individual Facebook profiles
- Posts published in Facebook groups
- Tweets published on individual Twitter profiles
- Fake reviews on business pages on Facebook
- Comments on posts, videos, or tweets
- Videos on TikTok
- Photos or captions on Instagram
- YouTube videos
Common Examples of Social Media Defamation in U.S. Courtrooms
False statements of fact and doctored photos can be defamatory, while genuine opinions generally are not. Here are some examples of social media defamation cases in U.S. courtrooms:
Musk Wins Twitter Defamation Case
Elon Musk, who later bought Twitter, has long been one of its most active users. In 2018, he landed in hot water over tweets about Vernon Unsworth, a British cave explorer who helped rescue a team of young soccer players trapped in a cave in Thailand. Musk called him a “pedo guy.”
Unsworth sued, and in December 2019 a Los Angeles jury found Musk not liable, surprising some defamation attorneys. The verdict showed how difficult it can be for juries to distinguish statements of fact from protected opinion.
One defamation lawyer, Chip Babcock, told Reuters in 2019: “I think this verdict reflects the feeling that internet tweets and chats are more like casual conversations which some may call opinion, rhetoric or hyperbole and must not be punished in a lawsuit.”
Cardi B Wins Her Defamation Case Against a YouTuber
Rapper and Grammy Award-winning artist Cardi B won more than $4 million, including about $1.3 million in legal fees, in her defamation lawsuit against YouTuber Tasha K and Kebe Studios LLC. Cardi B (Belcalis Almanzar) sued over false claims made in a series of videos about drug use, prostitution, her sexual health and her abilities as a mother.
The YouTuber, whose real name is Latasha Kebe, tried to present some proof in court, but it did not hold up. She admitted that she knew some of the rumors she spread were untrue, and she acknowledged that she is not a journalist, even though she has described herself as one on her channel. In an emotional testimony, Cardi B described her mental state caused by the videos and her thoughts of suicide.
At the end of the three-year lawsuit, the jury found the YouTuber liable for defamation, invasion of privacy and intentional infliction of emotional distress. In an opinion piece for NBC News, the writer argued that the victory means more than the money, serving as a warning to those who harass others online.
Hans Niemann Defamation Lawsuit
Hans Niemann, a 19-year-old chess grandmaster, defeated world champion Magnus Carlsen at the 2022 Sinquefield Cup, a tournament with a $350,000 prize fund, and Carlsen abruptly withdrew. A few weeks later, Carlsen posted a statement on Twitter accusing Niemann of cheating, without offering proof.
Another top chess player, Hikaru Nakamura, amplified the accusations on his Twitch channel. Niemann then filed a $100 million defamation lawsuit against Carlsen, Chess.com, Nakamura and others, including Chess.com’s chief chess officer, who was accused of making defamatory statements on the website. The young chess master says the defamatory actions destroyed his career and ruined his life. Carlsen’s legal team asked for the dismissal of the lawsuit, saying that his comments were protected by privilege and that he was not stating facts but his opinions.
Niemann has never been caught cheating in over-the-board play, but he admitted to cheating twice in online games on Chess.com when he was younger. In June 2023, a federal judge in Missouri dismissed the lawsuit’s antitrust claims and declined to rule on the defamation claims, leaving Niemann free to refile them in state court.
Lessons Learned From Examples of Social Media Defamation Cases
These cases show the consequences of making false allegations on social media. They also show that juries can have difficulty separating statements of fact from protected opinion, as in Elon Musk’s case, and they highlight the importance of verifying information before posting it. Finally, they illustrate how damaging online defamation can be, which is why anyone who has been defamed should act quickly to protect their rights.
Helpful Tips to Stay Clear of Social Media Defamation
To avoid becoming part of a defamation case, consider these tips:
- Exercise Caution: Always exercise caution when posting or commenting on social media. Your posts and comments are public and can be used against you in court.
- Think Before You Post: The internet has a long memory, and once a statement is published, it can be difficult, if not impossible, to fully retract or remove.
- Respect Privacy: Respect others’ privacy when posting or commenting on social media. Do not disclose private information about others without their consent.
- Understand the Law: Understanding the basics of what counts as defamation can prevent legal problems down the line.
- Refrain from Sharing Unverified Information: If you come across information damaging to another person or company, verify it before sharing. Sharing unverified damaging information can lead to a defamation lawsuit.
Being informed and careful about what you post can go a long way toward avoiding a defamation claim.
Final Take
As these cases show, social media defamation lawsuits often have mixed results, largely because outcomes depend on whether a statement is treated as fact or protected opinion. Anyone considering a claim should talk to an attorney, who will need to gather evidence before filing. It is also vital to file within the statute of limitations, the legal deadline to bring a claim, which for defamation is often short.
Social media companies themselves are usually shielded from defamation claims over what their users post. That protection comes from Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act, and one of the first courts to apply it was the 1997 decision in Zeran v. AOL.



