Supporters of legal marijuana argue that prohibition has failed to stop use, leads to hundreds of thousands of arrests a year, falls hardest on Black Americans, and leaves a large market to criminals instead of regulated, taxed businesses. They also point to medical uses, research on teen use, and comparisons with alcohol. Below are the 10 reasons they give most often, the main arguments on the other side, and where the law stands in 2026.
Twenty-four states and Washington, D.C. now allow recreational marijuana for adults, and 40 states have full medical marijuana programs. Under federal law, marijuana remains illegal except for a narrow change for medical products in April 2026.
10 Reasons Why Marijuana Should Be Legal
1. Adults should be able to decide for themselves.
Supporters argue that adults already may choose to drink alcohol and smoke tobacco, and that the government should not punish a personal choice that mainly affects the person making it.
2. Prohibition has not stopped people from using it.
An estimated 64.2 million Americans age 12 and older used marijuana in 2024, according to federal survey data reported by the Congressional Research Service. Supporters say decades of prohibition have not meaningfully reduced demand.
3. It would end hundreds of thousands of arrests.
Police made more than 200,000 marijuana arrests in 2024 according to FBI data, including about 188,000 for possession alone. A drug arrest or conviction can follow someone for years, affecting jobs, housing, student aid and immigration status.
4. Enforcement falls hardest on Black Americans.
Black and white Americans use marijuana at similar rates, but a 2020 ACLU analysis found Black people were 3.6 times more likely to be arrested for possession. Supporters see legalization as a way to end that disparity.
5. It raises tax revenue.
Colorado has collected more than $3.1 billion in marijuana taxes and fees since sales began in 2014, according to the Colorado Department of Revenue. Legal states use the money for schools, public health and other programs.
6. Regulated products are safer.
Legal products are tested for potency, pesticides and contaminants and carry labels showing how much THC they contain. Products from the illegal market have none of those checks.
7. It takes business away from criminals.
Every dollar spent at a licensed store is a dollar not going to an illegal seller. Supporters argue that legal sales shrink the illegal market and the violence that comes with it.
8. It has medical uses.
The FDA has approved a drug made from cannabis, Epidiolex, for certain rare seizure disorders, and synthetic THC drugs for nausea from chemotherapy and weight loss from AIDS. Many patients use marijuana for chronic pain and other conditions under state medical programs, though research on many uses is still limited.
9. Legalization has not increased teen use.
Two large studies published in JAMA journals in 2024, using survey data from hundreds of thousands of high school students, found that recreational legalization was not associated with an increase in teen marijuana use.
10. It is less dangerous than alcohol by some measures.
A 2015 study in Scientific Reports compared how close a typical dose of common drugs comes to a toxic dose and ranked alcohol as the highest risk and cannabis as the lowest of the substances it studied. Supporters argue the law should not treat marijuana more harshly than alcohol.
Arguments Against Legalization
Opponents and public health groups raise real concerns, and many people who support legalization agree some of them need attention.
- Addiction: about 3 in 10 people who use marijuana have cannabis use disorder, according to the CDC, and the risk is higher for people who start young or use often.
- Mental health: the CDC notes that cannabis use has been linked to schizophrenia, anxiety and depression, and today’s products are much stronger than in past decades.
- Young people: marijuana affects memory, attention and learning, and critics worry that commercial marketing and easy access will draw in teens.
- Impaired driving: marijuana slows reaction time and coordination, and there is no simple roadside test for impairment like there is for alcohol.
- Children and edibles: edibles packaged to look like candy and snacks have led to accidental poisonings of young children.
- The illegal market continues: in some legal states, high taxes and limited licenses have allowed illegal sellers to keep operating.
Some people take a middle position, such as supporting medical use only, decriminalizing possession without allowing commercial sales, or legalizing with strict limits on potency and advertising.
Where Marijuana Law Stands in 2026
State laws
Twenty-four states and Washington, D.C. have legalized recreational marijuana for adults, and about 53% of Americans live in one of them, according to Pew Research Center. Forty states have comprehensive medical marijuana programs, eight more allow limited low-THC or CBD products, and Idaho and Kansas allow neither. No state has repealed a medical or recreational law once passed.
Federal law
Marijuana is still a Schedule I controlled substance, the most restricted category, so growing, selling and possessing it remain federal crimes. On April 23, 2026, the Justice Department moved two narrow categories to the less restrictive Schedule III: FDA-approved marijuana drugs and marijuana sold under a state medical marijuana license. That change lets licensed medical businesses deduct ordinary business expenses on federal taxes, but it does not make recreational marijuana legal. A separate proposal to move all marijuana to Schedule III went through hearings in mid-2026 and was paused in late September.
Hemp and delta-8 THC
Congress also voted in November 2025 to close the loophole that allowed intoxicating hemp products such as delta-8 THC gummies and drinks to be sold nationwide. Under the new federal definition, most hemp products with more than 0.4 milligrams of total THC per container will no longer qualify as legal hemp. After a short delay, most of those changes take effect December 11, 2026. Learn more about the difference between hemp, CBD and marijuana.
Public opinion
Gallup found 64% of Americans supported legalization in 2025. In a January 2026 Pew survey, 55% said marijuana should be legal for both medical and recreational use, 33% said medical use only, and 11% said it should not be legal at all. For more on the money side, see our article on how legalization affects the economy.
Common Questions
Is marijuana legal federally?
No. Marijuana remains a federal controlled substance. In April 2026, FDA-approved marijuana drugs and marijuana sold under a state medical license were moved to Schedule III, but recreational marijuana is still illegal under federal law.
How many states have legalized recreational marijuana?
Twenty-four states and Washington, D.C. allow recreational marijuana for adults, and 40 states have comprehensive medical marijuana programs.
Was marijuana rescheduled to Schedule III?
Only in part. In April 2026, FDA-approved products and state-licensed medical marijuana moved to Schedule III. A proposal to reschedule all marijuana was paused in September 2026 and has not been finalized.
Does legalizing marijuana increase teen use?
Two large studies published in 2024 in JAMA Pediatrics and JAMA Psychiatry found recreational legalization was not associated with higher teen marijuana use, though one found that teens who already used did so more often where retail stores were open.
Is marijuana addictive?
It can be. The CDC estimates about 3 in 10 people who use marijuana have cannabis use disorder, with higher risk for those who start young or use frequently.
What are the main arguments against legalizing marijuana?
Opponents point to addiction, links to mental health problems, effects on young people, impaired driving, accidental poisonings of children from edibles, and the continued presence of illegal sellers in legal states.
What is happening to delta-8 and hemp THC products?
Congress narrowed the federal definition of hemp in November 2025. Starting December 11, 2026, most hemp products with more than 0.4 milligrams of total THC per container, including many delta-8 gummies and THC drinks, will no longer be legal hemp under federal law.


